GL claims: what typically happens next
General Liability (GL) claims are disruptive, even when they’re minor. An incident happens, someone alleges injury or damage, and suddenly paperwork, deadlines, and legal language appear. For many business owners, the uncertainty around “what comes next” is more stressful than the claim itself.
While every claim is fact-specific, GL claims tend to follow a predictable path. Understanding that path—incident reporting, demand letters, defense, documentation, and resolution—reduces friction, shortens timelines, and lowers the risk of coverage disputes.
The incident and initial report
Most GL claims begin with an incident that causes bodily injury, property damage, or an allegation of one.
- Common triggers: slip-and-falls, third-party property damage, product damage, completed-operations issues.
- Immediate response: ensure safety first; document conditions as they existed at the time.
- Timely reporting: notify your agent or carrier as soon as you’re aware of a potential claim.
Late reporting is one of the easiest ways to create unnecessary coverage issues. Many policies require notice “as soon as practicable.”
You don’t need to know the outcome to report a claim—you just need to know something happened.
Demand letters and allegations
Not every claim starts with a lawsuit. Many begin with a written demand or allegation.
-
Demand letters:
A formal request for payment alleging liability and damages.
These are not lawsuits—but they are serious and time-sensitive.
- Preservation requests: Requests to retain documents, footage, or records related to the incident.
- Verbal threats: Statements like “my lawyer will call” should still be reported.
Do not admit fault, promise payment, or negotiate directly without guidance. Forward all correspondence to your carrier or agent.
Early communication shapes the claim. Silence or improvisation often makes things worse.
Coverage review and legal defense
Once a claim is reported, the carrier evaluates whether it has a duty to defend and/or indemnify.
- Coverage analysis: policy terms, exclusions, endorsements, and timing are reviewed.
- Defense appointment: if covered, the insurer appoints defense counsel at its expense.
- Reservation of rights: sometimes issued when coverage questions exist.
A reservation of rights is not a denial—it means the carrier is defending while clarifying coverage boundaries.
Defense costs are often the most valuable part of GL coverage—even when claims ultimately go nowhere.
What documentation actually matters
Claims move faster—and with fewer disputes—when documentation is clear, consistent, and complete.
- Incident reports: date, time, location, conditions, witnesses, and immediate actions taken.
- Photos & video: conditions before cleanup or repair whenever possible.
- Contracts: agreements, scopes of work, indemnification clauses, and COI requirements.
- Maintenance logs: proof of reasonable care and routine upkeep.
- Correspondence: emails, texts, and letters related to the incident.
Claims are decided on facts, not memory. Documentation turns “what happened” into evidence.
Investigation, negotiation, and resolution
After defense is established, the claim moves through investigation and resolution.
- Fact investigation: statements, expert reviews, and scene analysis.
- Liability evaluation: comparative fault, causation, and damages assessed.
- Settlement discussions: negotiated resolutions when appropriate.
- Litigation: if settlement fails, the claim proceeds through court.
Many GL claims settle before trial. Litigation is slower, more expensive, and less predictable for all parties.
Most claims aren’t about “winning”—they’re about managing risk to an acceptable outcome.
How to reduce claim friction before and after a loss
The easiest claims are the ones prepared for in advance.
- Clear contracts: defined scope, indemnification, and insurance requirements.
- Accurate COIs: endorsements in place before work begins.
- Training & procedures: safety protocols and incident reporting workflows.
- Centralized records: keep contracts, COIs, and logs organized and accessible.
- Prompt communication: report incidents early and respond to requests quickly.
Claim friction is usually operational—not legal. Clean systems prevent messy outcomes.
Common questions
Should I call my carrier even if I think it’s minor?
Yes. Many “minor” incidents escalate later. Early notice preserves your rights.
Can I talk to the injured party directly?
You can be courteous, but avoid admissions, promises, or negotiations. Let the carrier manage liability discussions.
Will a claim raise my premium?
Not always. Severity, frequency, fault, and loss control matter more than a single reported incident.
Predictability beats panic
GL claims feel chaotic when the process is unfamiliar. In reality, most follow a clear sequence: report early, document thoroughly, let the carrier defend, and manage resolution strategically. Businesses that understand this flow experience fewer surprises and less disruption.